Editorial Policy
1. Scope of this Policy
This editorial policy applies to all content submitted to and published by the Revue des traditions musicales (RTM). It complements the “Aims and Scope” section, which defines the journal's scientific field, and the “Instructions for Authors” section, which details the practical submission procedures.
2. General Ethical Commitment
The RTM adheres to the principles and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), of the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME) in its recommendations applicable to the humanities, and, for any research involving human subjects (for example, informants or performers in fieldwork surveys, or participants in experimental studies), to the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. Manuscripts are evaluated solely on scientific merit, independently of the authors' origin, nationality, political or religious convictions, gender, or institutional affiliation.
3. Submission and Double-Blind Review Process
1. Online submission by the corresponding author on the RTM's editorial platform, in the form of two separate files: a title page identifying the author(s), and a fully anonymised manuscript (no mention allowing identification of the author in the body of the text, the file metadata, or first-person references to the author's prior work).
2. The corresponding author may suggest two to three potential reviewers, with no guarantee that they will actually be approached.
3. Initial review by the Editor(s)-in-Chief (or the relevant Associate Editor): conformity with the journal's scientific scope, scientific quality, compliance with presentation standards. A manuscript outside the journal's scope or clearly unfinished may be rejected at this stage, with a reasoned letter, without external review.
4. Appointment of at least two independent reviewers, chosen from within the international Editorial Review Board or, occasionally, from outside the board if the manuscript's specialty requires it — with no recent collaborative relationship or institutional proximity to the author.
5. Double-blind review: the identity of the author remains unknown to the reviewers, and vice versa. This review consists of:
• examining the anonymised manuscript, converted to PDF;
• completing a quantified evaluation grid for the manuscript, with written comments for the authors and, where relevant, written comments addressed exclusively to the editors;
• inserting comments in the manuscript's PDF;
• recommending to the Editor(s)-in-Chief one of the following four outcomes:
(1) acceptance of the manuscript without modification;
(2) acceptance of the manuscript subject to minor revisions/modifications;
(3) acceptance of the manuscript subject to major revisions/modifications;
(4) rejection of the manuscript.
6. Reasoned decision by the Editor(s)-in-Chief, among four possible outcomes: (1) acceptance, (2) minor revisions and resubmission of the manuscript, (3) major revisions and resubmission of the manuscript (entailing a return to the reviewers to check that the required revisions have been made), (4) rejection. In the event of disagreement between the two reviewers, a third opinion is sought before a decision.
Indicative timeframe: three to four weeks between submission and the first response to the author (decision or request for revision), subject to reviewer availability.
4. Conflict-of-Interest Policy
4.1 General Principle
Any member of the editorial team, the Managing Editor's office, the Editorial Review Board, or any ad hoc reviewer must declare, as soon as they become aware of it, any relationship likely to influence — or to give the appearance of influencing — their objectivity with respect to a given manuscript: recent or ongoing scientific collaboration with the author, a direct hierarchical or institutional relationship, a close personal relationship, or a financial interest. Authors, for their part, must declare their funding sources and any relevant financial relationship.
4.2 Recusal Policy for Editorial or Editorial Review Board Members Submitting a Manuscript to the RTM
In accordance with COPE's positions of principle on this scenario, a member of the editorial team, the Director of Publication, the Managing Editor's office, or the Editorial Review Board may submit a manuscript to the RTM, subject to strict compliance with the following procedure:
• Mandatory declaration of the author's relationship with the journal at the time the manuscript is submitted.
• Handling of the file entrusted exclusively to a person with no relationship to the author concerned, appointed from within the Editor(s)-in-Chief's office or, if the Co-Editors-in-Chief themselves are concerned, from within the international Editorial Review Board.
• The person affected by the conflict of interest takes part in no stage of the handling of their own manuscript: neither in the choice of reviewers, nor in monitoring the review, nor in the final decision.
• Double-blind review is maintained with respect to the reviewers, under the same conditions as for any other manuscript.
• Once the article is published, a notice is added indicating that the author is a member of the RTM's editorial team, Managing Editor's office, or Editorial Review Board, and that the manuscript was handled in accordance with this recusal procedure.
5. Editorial Exogeneity Policy
In order to preserve the journal's perceived and actual independence, the proportion of articles whose author or a co-author is a member of the Director of Publication's office, the editorial team, the Managing Editor's office, or the Editorial Review Board may not exceed 25% of the total articles published across the journal's latest two annual issues. Compliance with this ceiling is verified by the Editor(s)-in-Chief when each issue is closed.
6. Thematic Issues (Special Sections)
A thematic issue entrusted to one or more guest editors follows the same double-blind review process as ordinary issues. Articles authored or co-authored by a guest editor of the section may not exceed 25% of the section's content, and are handled in accordance with the RTM's conflict-of-interest procedure.
7. Scientific Integrity and Similarity Detection
• Any submitted manuscript must be original, must not have been previously published or be simultaneously submitted elsewhere, and must cite fully and accurately the sources and prior work on which it draws — including, where applicable, the field recordings, transcriptions or corpora used.
• Authorship presupposes a real and verifiable scientific contribution; all co-authors must have approved the submitted version and the final version prior to publication.
• Any research involving human subjects (fieldwork surveys, interviews, recordings of performers, experimental studies involving human participants) must state in the manuscript the informed consent of the persons concerned and the authorisation of the competent institutional ethics committee.
• Use of generative artificial-intelligence tools: any use of such tools beyond simple language editing must be declared in the manuscript; artificial intelligence may under no circumstances be designated as an author.
• Self-citation: limited to 20% of references or 5 citations (whichever is lower); citations to the same third-party author are limited to 4; self-citations of the journal itself are limited to 25% of references or 7 citations.
• Each manuscript undergoes a similarity check via Crossref's Similarity Check service (iThenticate access) prior to being sent to reviewers.
• Any well-founded suspicion of a breach of scientific integrity (plagiarism, falsification, redundant publication) is examined by the Editor(s)-in-Chief, in accordance with COPE guidelines, regardless of the author's relationship with the journal.
8. Corrections, Withdrawals and Retractions
• Erratum / corrigendum: for a minor error identified after publication (not affecting the article's scientific validity), a correction notice is published and linked to the original article, without altering its DOI.
• Retraction: reserved for established serious breaches of scientific integrity (clear plagiarism, falsified or fabricated data, undeclared duplicate publication) or an error fundamentally invalidating the article's conclusions. The decision is made by the Editor(s)-in-Chief, in accordance with COPE guidelines, and is the subject of a public retraction notice linked to the article, which remains accessible.
• These policies apply identically to any article, regardless of the author's status within the journal.
9. Open Access, Licensing and Copyright
• The RTM publishes in immediate and full open access, with no publication fee (APC) for authors and no access fee for readers (“Diamond / Platinum Open Access” model), with no embargo period.
• Licence: all articles are published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) licence, which permits sharing and adaptation of the content, including for commercial purposes, subject to proper attribution to the authors.
• The author retains all copyright in their text; they grant the RTM the non-exclusive right of first publication.
• Authors are permitted to deposit, with no embargo, the final version of their article in an institutional or subject-based archive of their choice.
• Data associated with an article (where applicable, reference lists, datasets) are made available under the Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication (CC0 1.0) licence.
10. Digital Preservation and Archiving
• Each published article receives a permanent Crossref DOI, guaranteeing its citability and traceability independently of any future change of platform.
• The journal is archived for the long term via the PKP Preservation Network (PKP PN), a free, permanent archiving network based on LOCKSS technology.
11. Publication Frequency
Articles are published on a rolling basis, as they are finalised (“advance publication”), and are then grouped into an issue once that issue is complete.
12. Complaints and Appeals
Any author, reviewer or reader may address a complaint concerning the handling of a manuscript, an editorial decision, or an alleged breach of scientific integrity to the Managing Editor's office, which forwards it to the Editor(s)-in-Chief. An author may appeal a rejection decision by setting out in writing the grounds for their disagreement; the Editor(s)-in-Chief rule on the appeal, where applicable after the opinion of a member of the international Editorial Review Board not involved in the initial review.
13. Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
The RTM is committed to building an international Editorial Review Board reflecting a diversity of geographic and institutional backgrounds and career paths, and to guaranteeing fair treatment of every manuscript, regardless of the author's country, academic status or resources.
14. Contact
Any question relating to this editorial policy may be addressed to the RTM's Managing Editor's office, whose contact details appear on the journal's editorial platform.